Use this one as you’d like, but here are some ideas:
- Award to the owner/coach whose ridiculous line-up selections cause them to lose an easy game.
- Bad draft pick, e.g., picking a kicker too high.
- It’s a bad trade.
- Etc., etc.
Disastrous Move Award – Fantasy Football

You can save a bunch by buying a bunch: Get the Complete Set of Fantasy Football Certificates.